Gel Eyeliner vs liquid Eyeliner: Which One Should You Choose?
When it comes to creating the perfect eye look, eyeliner is a must-have in any makeup bag. But with so many options available, it can be tough to decide which formula is right for you. Two of the most popular choices are liquid eyeliner and gel eyeliner. Each has its own unique benefits and drawbacks. So that why I have created this comparison guide; gel eyeliner vs liquid eyeliner.
Let’s break down the differences to help you find your perfect match!
I will also be giving some examples of both types of eyeliners. And don’t worry they are vegan as well as cruelty free!
Liquid Eyeliner: Precision and Drama
Liquid eyeliner is famous for its sharp, defined lines and bold color payoff. It usually comes in a small bottle with a fine-tipped brush or felt-tip applicator.
Pros:
- Precision: Perfect for creating crisp, clean lines and dramatic wings.
- Intensity: Offers a deep, rich color that stands out.
- Long-lasting: Many formulas are smudge-proof and stay put all day.
Cons:
- Tricky Application: Requires a steady hand and some practice.
- Less Forgiving: Mistakes can be harder to fix without starting over.
- Not Ideal for Blending: Best for sharp lines, not for smudged or smoky looks.
- Not ideal for waterline: It can irritate the eyes.
Some cool examples of vegan liquid eyeliners;
- Glossier liquid eyeliner – designed for precision, 12 hours of wear, dries quickly, beginner friendly
- Eyeko eye do -Vegan, smudge- and fade-proof up to 12 hours
- PHB ethical pure liquid eyeliner -All-natural, plant-based formula; vegan, cruelty-free, halal-certified; great for sensitive eyes
- fenty beauty fly liner – water-resistant, long-wearing liquid eyeliner with a hyper-pigmented, satin finish
- NYX epic ink eyeliner – Felt-tip eyeliner pen, intensely pigmented, waterproof; vegan as well as cruelty free
- KVD tattoo eyeliner – Award-winning, waterproof, vegan and cruelty-free liquid eyeliner with ultra-precise tip
Gel Eyeliner: Versatility and Control
Gel eyeliner typically comes in a small pot and is applied with an angled or fine-tipped brush. It’s known for its creamy texture and versatility.
Pros:
- Easy to Control: The creamy formula glides on smoothly, making it easier for beginners.
- Versatile: Great for both sharp lines and smudged, smoky effects. You can also use it to tight line, so on your waterline.
- Buildable: You can layer for more intensity or keep it subtle.
Cons:
- Requires a Brush: You’ll need a separate brush for application, which can be less convenient.
- Can Dry Out: Pots may dry out over time if not sealed properly.
- Slightly Less Intense: Color payoff can be softer compared to liquid liners.
Gel liner that are vegan:
- Pacifica smolder eye lining gel – infused with moisturising ingredients, easy to apply, free from junk, long lasting mineral colour
- Inglot AMC gel eyeliner – Available in black, brown, and white. Ultra-pigmented, waterproof, creamy, dries to a smudge-proof finish.
- Hourglass voyeur waterproof gel liner – 12 hour wear that is smudge proof, budge proof as well as waterproof, precise application.
- Revolution gel eyeliner pot – Matte finish thats rich in colour, affordable, bold pigment, comes with angled brush.
- Illamasque precision gel liner -Smooth, water-resistant, highly pigmented, and boasts excellent staying power
Which One Is Right for You? – Gel eyeliner vs liquid eyeliner
- Choose Liquid Eyeliner if: You love bold, dramatic looks and have a steady hand for precise application.
- Choose Gel Eyeliner if: You want versatility, easier application, and the option to create both sharp and smudged styles.
Ultimately, the best eyeliner for you depends on your personal style, skill level, and the look you want to achieve. Don’t be afraid to experiment—sometimes, having both in your makeup kit is the best solution! That way you can switch between whatever is best for the occasion or your mood.
Final Thoughts
Both liquid and gel eyeliners have their place in the world of makeup. Whether you’re aiming for a sleek cat-eye or a soft, smoky effect, there’s an eyeliner out there to help you express your unique and awesome style. There is also options of pencil eyeliners as well as felt tip too if you are looking for something a little different.
Right that is it for now, however if you don’t want to leave just yet then you can check out other types of eyeliners out there for you to experiment by tapping here!
Happy lining!
